Skip to Content

Crappie Fishing in Clear Water (Best Lures and Colors)

Crappie Fishing in Clear Water (Best Lures and Colors)

When the water is clear and visibility is high, crappie tend to be fairly active, and with the right lures and colors, you can expect plenty of bites and a lot of action.

With a presentation that won’t spook the fish, clear water crappie fishing can produce impressive results. If you stick to white, silver, chartreuse, and red jigs, inline spinners, or spinnerbaits, you’ll be sure to hook up with some great slabs. 

If you enjoy fishing in waters with high visibility, you are in for a true treat. Here is how you catch crappie in such conditions!

How Do You Catch Crappie in Clear Water? 

a happy angler on his boat holding a huge crappie that he has caught near a structure
Courtesy of Brian Harford

The most crucial thing you have to be aware of when fishing for crappie in clear water is light intensity. While they can be found in shallower areas during mornings, evenings, and on cloudy days, they tend to seek out deeper water during the daytime, when the sun is at its brightest.

This is an important aspect to consider because they tend to move away from the common crappie hangouts that you would normally target once the light gets too intense.

It’s also essential to take a closer look at how shallow they’ll move. Because while you can catch them in depths of only a foot or so in murky water, clear water crappie usually won’t go shallower than 4 to 5 feet (unless during spawning season, that is).

And so, if you can find grass flats and other areas of high vegetation around those 5 feet of water, you’re very likely to find the crappie there as well! They use the grass’ cover both as an ambush point and to get out of sight.

Retrieval speed is another essential part of crappie fishing in clear water conditions. 

When you fish for them in deeper water, slow trolling your lures can be very effective. Down there, the fish will move around quite a lot. Trolling for them out here in the open allows you to cover a lot of water, which increases your chance of finding the fish.

When targeting shallower depths, casting smaller lures that you can retrieve slowly above, or close to the weeds can be absolutely deadly for clear water crappie.

Some presentations work regardless of the water condition, but this is not always the case. Usually, it is best to create a setup specifically adapted to the water body you’re currently targeting.

What Are the Best Lures for Crappie in Clear Water?

an angler on a lake with a nice crappie caught on a jig
Courtesy of Brian Harford

Jigs

All in all, jigs are the best lure for crappie fishing in clear water. They’ll catch you fish year-round, and crappies love them!

When fishing near structures or vegetation, cast a light 1/16 ounce jig as close to the shade line as you dare.

When slow trolling over deeper water, fish a 3/16-1/8 ounce jig on a slip bobber rig and try out different depths until you hook up.

Check out a set of classic Marabou jigs that are perfect for clear water crappie fishing on Amazon right here

Berkley Nibbles

Berkley makes several great artificial crappie baits that thousands of anglers swear by. Their crappie nibbles are little bait balls that are chartreuse and have built-in attractants.

Tip your jigs or hooks with them for extra visual attraction and scent. On difficult days, these little baits can make all the difference!

You can check out Berkley’s Crappie Nibbles on Amazon here

Spinnerbaits

Along with sight, crappie take advantage of their lateral line to hunt for prey. Having a lure that creates a lot of vibration, flash, and motion can significantly increase your chances of catching difficult clear water crappie.

Additionally, spinnerbaits mimic minnows, which happen to be the primary food source for crappie.

Especially in the deeper water columns, they’ll hunt bigger schools of minnows, which is why using spinnerbaits down there in the deeper water is so effective for crappie!

If you’re new to crappie fishing, try your luck with a safety-pin spinnerbait. This type of lure is easy to cast and retrieve, and on light gear, you can cover a lot of water with it.

The Johnson Beetle Spin, which is a classic safety-pin spinner for crappie, also happens to be one of the best crappie lures out there! So, it’s a definite win-win!

Take a closer look at the Johnson Beetle Spin on Amazon here

Best Lure Colors for Clear Water Crappie 

Here are the most productive lure colors for clear water crappie fishing: 

  • White
  • Silver
  • Green/Chartreuse
  • Red

These colors stick out very well in clear water, and any combination of them is an excellent choice of lure color. 

In clear water, your choice of lure color becomes more flexible than in stained water conditions. 

If you fish for crappy in muddy water, you have to have lures that stick out and may not be all that natural. With clear water, you will always want to match the hatch. 

Matching the hatch means that your lure will match the size, action, and color of what crappie naturally eat. 

Since the fish are mostly sight feeders in clear water, using lures that look as natural as possible will significantly increase your chances of catching crappie. 

A very underrated color is red. Red signifies blood from an injured baitfish. You can mimic such easy prey simply by using red hooks or white jig heads with red in them. 

Also, look into white, silver, and chartreuse. These are very enticing when visibility is high, as such colors reflect sunlight very effectively. 

Should You Use a Leader for Crappie in Clear Water Conditions? 

a fisher on his boat holding two huge crappie caught on a jig and a thin fluorocarbon leader
Courtesy of Brian Harford

If you are going with a braided line, you should always use a thin fluorocarbon leader. When the water is clear, braided lines become very visible underwater and can easily spook the fish.

Choose an 8lb test fluorocarbon leader if you’re fishing near structures, vegetation, or other snags. 

If you’re trolling in deeper water without the risk of getting snagged, a 6lb test FC leader will suffice. 

If you are, on the contrary, already using a thin fluorocarbon och monofilament mainline, there is no sense in using an additional leader of the same material.

Just remember to avoid colorful mono lines, as they can also be pretty visible in the water.

Is Muddy or Clear Water Better for Crappie Fishing? 

As I’ve mentioned above, water condition can and does affect crappie patterns and how you can fish for them. Although there may be differing opinions within the angling community, clear water conditions can generally be considered better, or perhaps easier for crappie fishing. 

Fact: crappie are sight feeders! When they can spot their prey, they are very likely to go for it. 

However, if their sight is deterred, the entire fishing process becomes not necessarily more complicated but entirely different, which is something you should always be aware of when targeting crappie. 

When fishing in muddy water, you’ll have to use completely different colors and lure types to get the crappie’s attention. And if you don’t know what colors and lures to pick, this can be a pretty tough challenge! 

RELATED ARTICLE: If you would like more information about crappie fishing in dirty water, you should read the related article I wrote on the topic

So when it comes to crappie, clear water can definitely be your friend! It just makes things a little easier and more straightforward.

Most importantly, it can lead to more bites and action without the need for sophisticated lure presentations and fishing methods, which especially beginners highly appreciate. 

As long as you use the tips mentioned in this article, you will be in a good position to catch crappie.

Tight lines!

Related Articles

Featured image courtesy of Brian Harford

Ice Fishing on Lake Nipissing (A Helpful Guide)
← Previous
When Do Perch Spawn? (Times, Temperatures, Locations)
Next →